Wednesday, October 13, 2010

IL Pollution Control Board Issues $20,000 Penalty to Clean Construction and Demolition Debris Fill Business

The Illinois Pollution Control recently entered summary judgment against one of the defendants in People v. 87th & Greenwood, LLC, No. PCB 10-71, which concerned a storage facility located at 1040 E. 87th Street, Chicago, Cook County, IL and a clean construction and demolition debris fill business operated by Land Reclamation Services ("LRS") located at 1127 South Chicago Street, Joliet, Will County, IL.

The State alleged that defendants violated the Illinois Environmental Protection Act by causing and allowing the disposal of waste at the LRS site, disposing of waste at the LRS site that was not permitted for waste disposal by the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency (the "IEPA"), and causing and allowing the disposal of approximately 350 truckloads of waste at the LRS Site, thereby conducting a waste disposal operation without a permit.  IEPA inspectors found that the soil taken to the LRS Site contained a number of compounds at levels which exceeded background levels for both the City of Chicago and the Chicago Metropolitan Area.  These contaminants included benzo(a)anthracene, carbazole, cadmium, copper, iron, lead, magnesium, beryllium, antimony, and total chromium.

The State filed a motion to deem facts admitted and for summary judgment against LRS, who failed to file an answer to the State's complaint in this case.  The Illinois Pollution Control Board granted the motion and directed LRS to pay a civil penalty of $20,000.

Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Individual Settles State Water Enforcement Action for $12,000

The Illinois Pollution Control Board recently accepted the parties' settlement of People v. Rawson, Case No. PCB 09-91, which concerned a sanitary sewer and potable water lines to service future residential subdivisions in the City of Crystal Lake, McHenry County, Illinois.

The State alleged that the Rawson violated state environmental laws by "by causing, threatening, or allowing the discharge of a contaminant into the environment so as to cause or tend to cause water pollution; by depositing contaminants onto the land so as to create a water pollution hazard; and by allowing storm water discharges in violation the general National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) storm water permit for construction site activities."

Under the settlement terms, Rawson did not affirmatively admit the alleged violations but agreed to pay a civil penalty of $12,000.

Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.

Saturday, October 9, 2010

You're Invited: Careers in Environmental Law Seminar on 10/29/10

As co-chair of the Environmental Law Committee of the Chicago Bar Association Young Lawyers Section, I am pleased to invite you to our Careers in Environmental Law seminar:

Careers in Environmental Law

Date: 10/29/2010

Time: 2:00 PM - 3:30 PM

Location: The Chicago Bar Association, 321 South Plymouth Court, Chicago, IL 60604

Hear a panel of environmental practitioners discuss their career paths and the practical differences between the different areas of environmental law. The panelists will also share advice for law students and newer attorneys seeking to enter the practice area.

PANELISTS

Renee Cipriano, Partner, Schiff Hardin

Allison Torrence, Associate, Jenner & Block

Jessica Dexter, Attorney at the Environmental Law and Policy Center

Edward Manzke, Partner, Collins Law Firm

Sharon Neal, Assistant General Counsel, Environmental, Corporate, and Commercial Law Department, Exelon Business Services

MODERATORS

David Johnson, Esq.

David Scriven-Young, Peckar & Abramson, P.C.
 
A networking reception will follow the seminar.  The seminar is free for CBA members and only $15 for nonmembers.  To register for the seminar, please click here.
 
I hope to see you there!

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Federal Court Allows Contribution and Indemnity Claims Against Drainage & Levee District to Proceed

The U.S. District Court for the Central District of Illinois recently issued an opinion in Wilder Corp. v. Thompson Drainage and Levee District, Case No. 09-1322.  I first reported on this case when the Court dismissed the plaintiff's original complaint in May 2010 (click here).

In this case, Wilder seeks contribution and indemnification from Thompson Drainage and Levee District, to the extent that Wilder is found liable in a different case brought by the Nature Conservancy for breaches of various agreements related to the Conservancy's purchase of certain land in Fulton County, Illinois from Wilder.

The District filed a motion to dismiss Wilder's Second Amended Complaint.  The Court denied the motion.

Count I of the Second Amended Complaint alleged a claim for contribution based on the District's contamination of the property, to the extent that Wilder is held liable to the Conservancy for damages related to the contamination.  The Court held that Count I properly "put the District on notice of its allegation that it could have been liable to Wilder for its role in the pollution of the Property according to the Illinois Tortfeasor Act.  Wilder alleges for that at the time of the first suit, the Conservancy could have also claimed that Wilder was liable in tort for negligence and lack of due care in allowing the damage caused by the pollution.  This is marginally sufficient to promote a reasonable inference of a joint tortfeasor relationship at this stage of the proceedings."

Count II contains the more interesting claim.  It alleged a claim for indemnity based on an implied warranty made by the District to Wilder.  Wilder "alleges the existence of a pre-tort relationship based on the District's use of its property daily since 1918 pursuant to a right of way."  Specifically, Wilder claimed that "by running a petroleum pipe across its property, the District impliedly promised to indemnify Wilder from any and all damages that occurred as a result of the District's actions or inactions.  Wilder further alleges that as a result, they should be indemnified and held harmless by the District against the prior judgment [against Wilder] regarding the contamination. . . . Through its Complaint, Wilder has pled sufficient facts to put the District on notice of its allegation that Wilder should be indemnified against the prior judgment."

Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

In Disjointed Opinion, IL Appellate Court Affirms Grant of Petition to Delist Residue as Hazardous Waste

The Appellate Court of Illinois, Third District, recently issued an opinion in Sierra Club v. Illinois Pollution Control Board, Case No. 3-09-0120, which concerned Peoria Disposal Company's ("PDC") permit to operate a waste stabilization facility near Peoria, Illinois, for the storage and treatment of hazardous and nonhazardous waste.  PDC filed a petition with the Illinois Pollution Control Board to delist residue resulting from the treatment of electric arc furnace dust ("EAFD") as a hazardous waste for disposal purposes, after the EAFD is treated and stabilized. 

The Pollution Control Board issued an order granting PDC's petition, subject to several conditions.  Two groups, Sierra Club and Peoria Families Against Toxic Waste, filed an appeal seeking reversal of the Board's order, arguing that the Board erred in (1) failing to consider the factors set forth in the relevant statute, (2) not requiring PDC to address future permit modifications; (3) finding that local citing approval was not required; and (4) not requiring reopener language.  PDC and the Board argued that the opposition groups did not have standing to appeal the Board’s order.

Each appellate court justice on the three-justice panel came to a different conclusion concerning this appeal:

(1) Justice Lytton (delivering the "opinion of the court") found that the opposition groups had standing because they were persons "adversely affected or threatened" by the delisting.  However, Justice Lytton affirmed the Board's order on the merits of the case, finding that the Board properly granted PDC's petition.

(2) Justice Carter specially concurred in the judgment, reasoning that the opposition groups did not have standing to bring the appeal. 

(3) Justice Wright concurred in part and dissented in part, reasoning that the opposition groups did have standing, but concluding that the Board's decision was arbitrary and capricious because the Board did not make required factual findings. 

The opinions of Justices Lytton and Carter combined to dismiss the appeal.  However, it will be interesting to see what will happen with the standing issue if this case gets decided by the Illinois Supreme Court.

Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.

Monday, September 27, 2010

Environmental Register for August 2010

The Illinois Pollution Control Board has issued its Environmental Register publication for August 2010.

The Environmental Register features a letter from Chairman Girard, which discusses five environmental bills that Governor Quinn recently signed into law.  The Environmental Register also contains an appellate court update, a rulemaking update, a summary of actions of the Board, a summary of new cases, a list of provisional variances, and the Board's calendar.

Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.

Thursday, September 23, 2010

Illinois ENERGY STAR® Appliance Rebate Program--Friday, September 24th

On Friday September 24th, Illinois residents can receive a 15% off instant discount at the point of sale, up to $250, on an ENERGY STAR qualified model for washers, dishwashers, freezers, or refrigerators.  This program is sponsored by the Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity and the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009.

Note that this is an appliance replacement program.  Customers must complete a self-certification form attesting that the appliance purchased is for replacement purposes.

For more details on the program, you can click here or call 877-782-7005.

Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.