The Appellate Court of Illinois, Third District, recently issued an opinion in Quick v. Shell Oil Co., No. 3-09-0987, which concerned a class action settlement arising out of a release of thousands of gallons of gasoline from a Shell pipeline onto the Danhausen farm in Limestone Township, Kankakee County, Illinois.
The settlement agreement provided a fund of $26 million to be distributed by a settlement administrator, who in turn consulted a licensed real estate appraiser, Jay M. Heap, to determine the diminution in value of property in the class area resulting from the gasoline release. The trial court approved the settlement administrator’s recommendation to distribute $120,489 of the settlement fund to the Danhausen estate.
The Danhausen estate filed an appeal, arguing that an award of $1,172,300 for diminution in value and $3,516,900 for nuisance and interference with quiet enjoyment would be more appropriate. The estate based its calculations on its own appraiser, Richard F. Hansen. The appellate court disagreed and affirmed the trial court's order:
"Regarding the award for diminution in value of the Danhausen estate property, the court found Heap’s appraisal to be worthy of greater weight than that of Hansen, due to Heap’s credentials and experience. We have reviewed both Heap’s and Hansen’s appraisals and cannot find that the trial court’s decision in this regard was arbitrary, fanciful or unreasonable. In addition, considering the large number of claimants and the lengthy time period that has elapsed since the gasoline spill, we cannot find that the trial court’s decision to approve the Settlement Administrator’s use of a formulaic approach to approximate agricultural property values and the diminution in value of those pieces of property was unfair, unreasonable, or inadequate. Thus, the trial court’s decision to approve the Settlement Administrator’s award to the Danhausen estate for diminution in value was not an abuse of discretion.
"We also conclude that the trial court did not abuse its discretion by approving the recommended distribution to the Danhausen estate for nuisance and interference with quiet enjoyment of its property. The Danhausen estate maintains it is entitled to more than $3 million for this claim. However, it does not provide any legal or factual support for its claim. On the other hand, the Settlement Administrator’s formula for compensating Core Area property owners for nuisance and interference with quiet enjoyment of their property, taken as a whole, was fair, reasonable and adequate. While it is undisputed that the gasoline spill occurred on the Danhausen estate’s property, it did not present adequate evidence that it was entitled to a larger distribution of the settlement fund for these damages."
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
Sunday, October 24, 2010
Saturday, October 23, 2010
Illinois Appellate Court Allows Claims Alleging that Coal Mine Waste Contaminated Community Drinking Water Supply
The Appellate Court of Illinois, Fifth District, recently issued an opinion in Citizens Opposing Pollution v. ExxonMobil Coal U.S.A., Case No. 05-09-0207, which concerned a coal mine owned by Monterey Coal (a division of ExxonMobil Coal U.S.A.) and located near Albers, Illinois. From 1977 until August 1996, when the mine closed, a coal preparation plant and two coal refuse and slurry disposal areas operated on the property.
The plaintiff-citizens' organization filed a lawsuit seeking to obtain injunctive relief to cause ExxonMobil to remove and properly dispose of slurried coal production waste, which was allegedly leaching into the community drinking water supply known as the Pearl Sand Aquifer. Plaintiff brought its claims under the Surface Coal Mining Land Conservation and Reclamation Act and the Water Use Act of 1983. The trial court granted the defendants' motion to dismiss the plaintiff's complaint, and this appeal followed.
The Appellate Court reversed the trial court's decision. The Appellate Court held that, because Plaintiff challenged ExxonMobil's compliance with its permits and did not challenge the actual issuance of permits, Plaintiff was allowed to bring an action under the Surface Coal Mining Land Conservation and Reclamation Act.
The Court also held that Plaintiff could bring an enforcement action under the Water Use Act, which requires that groundwater withdrawal must be done following the "reasonable use" rule, which is defined as "the use of water to meet natural wants and a fair share of artificial wants. It does not include water used wastefully or maliciously." According to the complaint, ExxonMobil is withdrawing four million gallons of water per week from the Pearl Sand Aquifer in order to keep contaminated groundwater within the boundaries of the permit.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
The plaintiff-citizens' organization filed a lawsuit seeking to obtain injunctive relief to cause ExxonMobil to remove and properly dispose of slurried coal production waste, which was allegedly leaching into the community drinking water supply known as the Pearl Sand Aquifer. Plaintiff brought its claims under the Surface Coal Mining Land Conservation and Reclamation Act and the Water Use Act of 1983. The trial court granted the defendants' motion to dismiss the plaintiff's complaint, and this appeal followed.
The Appellate Court reversed the trial court's decision. The Appellate Court held that, because Plaintiff challenged ExxonMobil's compliance with its permits and did not challenge the actual issuance of permits, Plaintiff was allowed to bring an action under the Surface Coal Mining Land Conservation and Reclamation Act.
The Court also held that Plaintiff could bring an enforcement action under the Water Use Act, which requires that groundwater withdrawal must be done following the "reasonable use" rule, which is defined as "the use of water to meet natural wants and a fair share of artificial wants. It does not include water used wastefully or maliciously." According to the complaint, ExxonMobil is withdrawing four million gallons of water per week from the Pearl Sand Aquifer in order to keep contaminated groundwater within the boundaries of the permit.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
Labels:
Citizen Suits,
Groundwater Contamination,
Mines
Friday, October 22, 2010
Owner of Landfill Settles State Enforcement Action Alleging Methane Gas Violations
The Illinois Pollution Control Board recently accepted the parties' stipulation and proposed settlement in People v. Roxana Landfill, Inc., Case No. PCB 11-4, which concerned the defendant's landfill facility at 4601 Cahokia Road in Roxana, Madison County, Illinois.
The State alleged that the defendant violated Illinois environmental laws and regulations by (1) failing to notify the Illinois EPA within two business days of observed exceedances of methane gas limits, (2) conducting a waste-storage, waste-treatment, or waste-disposal operation in violation of regulations or standards adopted by the Pollution Control Board, and (3) conducting a waste-storage, waste-treatment, or waste-disposal operation in violation of a condition within the operating permit by failing to submit an application to the IEPA for significant modification within 180 days of the occurrences.
Under the terms of the settlement, the defendant does not affirmatively admit the alleged violations but agrees to pay a civil penalty of $10,000 and complete a supplemental environmental project
consisting of landfill disposal services with a settlement value of $18,000.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
The State alleged that the defendant violated Illinois environmental laws and regulations by (1) failing to notify the Illinois EPA within two business days of observed exceedances of methane gas limits, (2) conducting a waste-storage, waste-treatment, or waste-disposal operation in violation of regulations or standards adopted by the Pollution Control Board, and (3) conducting a waste-storage, waste-treatment, or waste-disposal operation in violation of a condition within the operating permit by failing to submit an application to the IEPA for significant modification within 180 days of the occurrences.
Under the terms of the settlement, the defendant does not affirmatively admit the alleged violations but agrees to pay a civil penalty of $10,000 and complete a supplemental environmental project
consisting of landfill disposal services with a settlement value of $18,000.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
Thursday, October 21, 2010
U.S. EPA Settles Superfund Claims With Potentially Responsible Parties at Gilberts/Kedzie Site
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency recently provided notice in the Federal Register of an administrative settlement for recovery of past response costs concerning the Gilberts/Kedzie Site in the Village of Gilberts, Illinois with the following settling parties: Glen J. Kedzie, Big Timber Landscape Company, Inc., and GTCS Corp.
The site is the location of a former battery cracking and recycling operation. The main site is located immediately north of the intersection of Railroad and Mill Streets bounded by Galligan Road on the east and the Chicago and Northwestern Railway on the west. Lead acid batteries were cracked open to recover the lead. Some of the lead seeped into the ground along with the acid contained in the batteries. Extensive environmental sampling last summer identified a six-acre area of gross contamination (mainly lead). Later, a second area of contamination was discovered to the southwest, where the Village of Gilberts Public Works building is now located, west of the railroad tracks - this is known as the Tower Hill Road site.
The settlement requires the settling parties to pay $3,000.00 to the Hazardous Substance Superfund and additional payments when the Site is sold. The settlement includes a covenant not to sue the settling parties pursuant to Section 107(a) of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, 42 U.S.C. 9607(a).
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
The site is the location of a former battery cracking and recycling operation. The main site is located immediately north of the intersection of Railroad and Mill Streets bounded by Galligan Road on the east and the Chicago and Northwestern Railway on the west. Lead acid batteries were cracked open to recover the lead. Some of the lead seeped into the ground along with the acid contained in the batteries. Extensive environmental sampling last summer identified a six-acre area of gross contamination (mainly lead). Later, a second area of contamination was discovered to the southwest, where the Village of Gilberts Public Works building is now located, west of the railroad tracks - this is known as the Tower Hill Road site.
The settlement requires the settling parties to pay $3,000.00 to the Hazardous Substance Superfund and additional payments when the Site is sold. The settlement includes a covenant not to sue the settling parties pursuant to Section 107(a) of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, 42 U.S.C. 9607(a).
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
Tuesday, October 19, 2010
Environmental Register for September 2010
The Illinois Pollution Control Board has issued its Environmental Register publication for September 2010.
The Environmental Register features a letter from Chairman Girard, which discusses progress that the Board made in a number of open rulemaking dockets. The Environmental Register also contains a rulemaking update, a summary of actions of the Board, a summary of new cases, a list of provisional variances, and the Board's calendar.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
The Environmental Register features a letter from Chairman Girard, which discusses progress that the Board made in a number of open rulemaking dockets. The Environmental Register also contains a rulemaking update, a summary of actions of the Board, a summary of new cases, a list of provisional variances, and the Board's calendar.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
Monday, October 18, 2010
Defendant Agrees to Pay Penalty for Failure to Provide Notification Concerning Tire Storage
The Illinois Pollution Control Board recently accepted the parties' settlement of People v. Pickett, Case No. PCB 10-87, which concerned the defendant's used car lot at 1401 Broadway, Rockford, Winnebago County, Illinois. The State alleged that the defendant violated the Illinois Environmental Protection Act by failing to notify the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency that defendant was operating a tire storage site and failing to register and pay a fee for the tire storage site.
Under the terms of the settlement, the defendant admits the alleged violations and agrees to pay a civil penalty of $1,340.00.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
Under the terms of the settlement, the defendant admits the alleged violations and agrees to pay a civil penalty of $1,340.00.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
Sunday, October 17, 2010
Seventh Circuit Rules That Clean Air Act's Citizen-Suit Provision Cannot Be Used To Enforce Illinois' "Prohibition Of Air Pollution" Or "Fugitive Particulate Matter" Regulations
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit ruled, in McEvoy v. IEI Barge Services, Inc., No. 09-3494, that the federal Clean Air Act's citizen-suit provision cannot be used to enforce Illinois' "Prohibition of Air Pollution" and "Fugitive Particulate Matter" regulations.
In this case, the defendant stored coal in outdoor piles and then loaded the coal onto river barges. As the defendant moved the coal around, coal dust was thrown into the air. One of the company's neighbors objected to the coal dust because it was drifting into his home. The plaintiff sued under the Clean Air Act's citizen-suit provision, which provides private citizens the right to bring civil actions in federal courts against, among others, violators of emission standards or limitations. Plaintiff sued under the theory that the defendant violated two Illinois regulations. The first is entitled “Prohibition of Air Pollution,” which provides:
"No person shall cause or threaten or allow the discharge or emission of any contaminant into the environment in any State so as, either alone or in combination with contaminants from other sources, to cause or tend to cause air pollution in Illinois, or so as to violate the provisions of this Chapter, or so as to prevent the attainment or maintenance of any applicable ambient air quality standard."
The second is the “Fugitive Particulate Matter” regulation, which states:
"No person shall cause or allow the emission of fugitive particulate matter from any process, including any
material handling or storage activity, that is visible by an observer looking generally toward the zenith at a point beyond the property line of the source."
The trial court granted summary judgment to the defendant, concluding that the Clean Air Act did not provide a private right of action to enforce the two Illinois regulations. The Seventh Circuit affirmed and held that neither of the Illinois regulations was an "emission standard or limitation" that could be enforced through the Clean Air Act's citizen-suit provision. The Court reasoned that the regulations did not limit the quantity, rate, or concentration of emissions.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
In this case, the defendant stored coal in outdoor piles and then loaded the coal onto river barges. As the defendant moved the coal around, coal dust was thrown into the air. One of the company's neighbors objected to the coal dust because it was drifting into his home. The plaintiff sued under the Clean Air Act's citizen-suit provision, which provides private citizens the right to bring civil actions in federal courts against, among others, violators of emission standards or limitations. Plaintiff sued under the theory that the defendant violated two Illinois regulations. The first is entitled “Prohibition of Air Pollution,” which provides:
"No person shall cause or threaten or allow the discharge or emission of any contaminant into the environment in any State so as, either alone or in combination with contaminants from other sources, to cause or tend to cause air pollution in Illinois, or so as to violate the provisions of this Chapter, or so as to prevent the attainment or maintenance of any applicable ambient air quality standard."
The second is the “Fugitive Particulate Matter” regulation, which states:
"No person shall cause or allow the emission of fugitive particulate matter from any process, including any
material handling or storage activity, that is visible by an observer looking generally toward the zenith at a point beyond the property line of the source."
The trial court granted summary judgment to the defendant, concluding that the Clean Air Act did not provide a private right of action to enforce the two Illinois regulations. The Seventh Circuit affirmed and held that neither of the Illinois regulations was an "emission standard or limitation" that could be enforced through the Clean Air Act's citizen-suit provision. The Court reasoned that the regulations did not limit the quantity, rate, or concentration of emissions.
Stay tuned to the Illinois Environmental Law Blog for more news and developments.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
